Review: INDEPENDENCE DAY: RESURGENCE Should Have Stayed Dead

Contributor; Seoul, South Korea (@pierceconran)
to Vote
Review: INDEPENDENCE DAY: RESURGENCE Should Have Stayed Dead

The first movie I remember renting was Independence Day, and during the 48 hours I had it, I probably watched it six or seven times. For a young kid, the charisma of its leads, the iconic imagery of its set pieces and its simple good vs. evil plotting added up to an irresistible package. 20 years on, director Roland Emmerich and producer Dean Devlin have returned to the well for Independence Day: Resurgence. The original was a fun, campy b-movie with a huge budget, but this sequel is an utter failure in almost every regard. So much so, that it makes me wish the aliens had won at the end of the first movie. That would have robbed us of ID4's fist-pumping finale, but also saved us from this pricey monstrosity.

20 years after the people of Earth came together to repel alien invaders, the human race once again faces extinction. Ex-President Whitmore (Bill Pullman) and the kooky Dr. Brakish Okun (Brent Spiner), who apparently didn't die in the first instalment, are both getting headaches and premonitions of an alien invasion. A downed spaceship in Africa has sent out a distress call and not long after a mysterious spherical ship appears before a defence base on the moon and is promptly shot down on orders from the United Nations. Science whiz David Levinson (Jeff Goldblum) hops on a ride to the moon, along with a foxy French scientist and an African warlord, to inspect the felled craft. Then the real threat comes, a mothership 3,000 miles wide that plants itself over the entire Atlantic Ocean.

Special effects have come a long way in 20 years and the team behind Resurgence clearly felt the need to up the ante. While the new elements are certainly bigger, they're also clunky and silly, but not in a fun way. Replacing the unforgettable images of monuments being blown to smithereens by an alien beam of light are jumbled vistas of cities being torn apart by the gravitational pull of the extravagantly large alien ship.

Gone too is the charm of the original's cast. Will Smith's cocky pilot has died in the interim between the films and is replaced by his grown up stepson, also a pilot, played with the charisma of an office chair by Jessie T. Usher. Other new additions include a woefully drab Liam Hemsworth as a brave orphan pilot, a gormless Maika Monroe as Whitmore's grownup daughter/presidential aide/pilot and HK star Angelababy as, you guessed it, a pilot. A crass attempt to woo the Chinese film market, Angelababy's character is a very poor fit in an already leaden cast of new recruits and is exacerbated by some bad Chinese product placement (space milk, anyone?). Returning cast members fare marginally better, with Goldblum somewhat charming though fed less convincing one-liners, Judd Hirsh tottering around for no ostensible reason and Bill Pullman seeming a little raspier and the worse for wear. William Fichtner is fine as top military brass and poor Charlotte Gainsbourg is given nothing to do as Goldblum's maybe love interest.

The plot of Resurgence doesn't make a great deal of sense, but this issue didn't hurt the first film, nor did its corny dialogue. What does hurt is the absence of fun. The plotting is murky, elements fly in thick and fast without being given the time to stick and we're never given the chance to develop any fondness for the characters. Without ID4's simplicity and its appealing characters it's hard to imagine young viewers falling in love with this lazy followup in the same way.

An awkward summer tentpole that fails to match its hefty price tag with any heart or innovation, Independence Day: Resurgence spends 90 minutes vainly swinging for the fences before falling back on its roots in an overly familiar final reel.

Independence Day: Resurgence

  • Roland Emmerich
  • Nicolas Wright (screenplay)
  • James A. Woods (screenplay)
  • Dean Devlin (screenplay)
  • Roland Emmerich (screenplay)
  • James Vanderbilt (screenplay)
  • Dean Devlin (story by)
  • Roland Emmerich (story by)
  • Nicolas Wright (story by)
  • James A. Woods (story by)
  • Dean Devlin (based on characters created by)
  • Roland Emmerich (based on characters created by)
  • Liam Hemsworth
  • Jeff Goldblum
  • Jessie T. Usher
  • Bill Pullman
to Vote
Screen Anarchy logo
Do you feel this content is inappropriate or infringes upon your rights? Click here to report it, or see our DMCA policy.
alien invasionid4independence dayrolan emmerichsequelsummer blockbusterRoland EmmerichNicolas WrightJames A. WoodsDean DevlinJames VanderbiltLiam HemsworthJeff GoldblumJessie T. UsherBill PullmanActionAdventureSci-Fi

More about Independence Day: Resurgence

Around the Internet

LysanderJune 21, 2016 1:03 PM

When the first film came out there were folks saying the spaceships could do more damage with their anti-gravity engines than their giant lasers. The common rebuttal was "while possibly accurate, it's much less visually interesting." Somehow the producers of the sequel missed the rebuttals during the two decades of fans nostalgically dissecting their movie.

It's peculiar that despite the world uniting to defend themselves from the alien threat, and gaining advances from captured alien technology, Africa seems to remain both war-torn and largely ignored by the rest of Earth. Somehow a stranded colony of aliens is completely overlooked over twenty years.

Is this some sort of awkward message about society and tech advancement, which has been repeated ad nauseum from the Industrial Revolution onward? Are the writers clinging to themes started by Charles Dickens and not actually doing anything to evolve beyond it?

The trailer left me expecting a bright alternate future, where humanity was heading toward a golden age -- only to face the horror that despite that, their previous nemesis still considers them insignificant. That would have been cool, but it looks like that isn't the story I'm going to get.

Darren MurrayJune 24, 2016 9:17 AM

Watched this last night. Thought it was a total car crash of a film. Sure the original was just a big budget B movie, but it was done very well. The original was set in a recognisable environment, and had some great visuals with fighter jets going against alien space ships. This is set in a total sci fi world, with the humans having their own space ships, warp speed and the usual shite. Seems like Emmerich just wanted an excuse to have a lot of special effects included.

The three leads were also great. I didn't think at the time it would matter that Will Smith would be missing from the sequel, but the film seriously needs someone with that star power, which unfortunately the new leads dont have. Jeff Goldblum is still the best thing in the film, and Bill Pullman is also good but totally wasted.