Make no mistake The Guard is not a buddy cop movie or a bromance, but is sensible and authentic. The scenes of awkward racism with Gerry towards Wedell are not overstated or exploited and feel natural as part of a harmless but offhandedly offensive verbal exchange. Wendell remarks to Gerry that he must be "either really fucking smart or really fucking stupid" and this is the strength of The Guard, characters that are genuinely funny to watch and hear but do not overstep the boundaries and become moronic for comedy-sake. They are grounded in their roles as absurd as they are and include a philosophical sociopathic assassin, a greedy unmoral police commissioner and Mark Strong in particular; who as Clive gives a command performance as an unlikely criminal that is cynical, tired and has a death wish. His scenes are some of the high lights; one in particular has him question the morals and ethics of criminals in a scene where he gives some corrupt policeman pay-off money to allow himself to conduct the trafficking business. In an all-too-typical trope referring to the briefcase full of bills they question "is it all there?" His reply is both extremely funny and critical of the standard genre conventions.
itself is a perfectly bizarre one for such a massive criminal operation. Even
if half the police were not in on the illegal action their resources would
probably be too few and thus enter the FBI. Cheadle gives a nuanced performance
of a frustrated man lost in translation and culture. His base responses to the
small town folk and their extremely limited views are comedy gold, in the end
he inquires with a horse, because at this point the delineation of
communication is comparable to talking with the ignorant locals.
The small town
colloquialisms are almost reminiscent of the Cohen brothers, only without the
poetry of the dialogue prevalent in most of their works. None the less the
small town setting makes for an interesting sort of psychosis, and most of this
is utilized in the kid. A creepy tyke on a bike who knows way more than he
should and is a macguffin for Gerry to move the bare plot along, not that there
is anything wrong with that.
Director John Michael McDonagh has made great use of the setting. Although it is a fairly bland little village, each scene is so descriptive and acts as a set piece reflecting the mood in the choice props and lighting. The Guard is told through the point of view of Gerry and thus it almost barely feels like there is any connection to the lawful institutions. He is a vigilante; a man on a mission who knows the consequences of his actions but martyrs himself for the greater good. Although loosely defined, the mission drives him to the perfect conclusion and in its own way answers the question Wendell so brashly put; is he so fucking smart or so fucking stupid?