Pingyao 2017 Review: A FISH OUT OF WATER Revamps Family-At-Distress Narrative Through the Eyes of An Unusual Child

Contributor; Slovakia (@martykudlac)
Sign-In to Vote
Pingyao 2017 Review: A FISH OUT OF WATER Revamps Family-At-Distress Narrative Through the Eyes of An Unusual Child

Seasoned Taiwanese music video and commercial director Lai Kuo-An ventures into feature-length fiction storytelling in his debut A Fish Out of Water. A trope of its own, the title refers to a young character, pre-schooler Yi-An, and his slightly confused and cautious social interactions within his family as well as his immediate environment.

The only child of a young couple Yaji and Haoteng seems to inhabit a different reality incessantly mentioning his "first mother and father" and "their life" in Toyama. He longs to return to Toyama. The writer-director unspools a cryptic premise of a troubled child and the mystery of its origin.

What looks like another coming-of-age drama never fulfils the genre conventional expectations and rather forays into a dysfunctional family territory. As Haoteng struggles with his small restaurant and his wife Yaji with selling apartments, the responsibilities of being a parent and a child drive a wedge between the couple. They have to not only take care of their small son suffering uncertain syndrome but of Haoteng´s incapacitated father stricken probably with severe Alzheimer's as well.

Lai Kuo-An embraces the ambiguity which doubles as a curiosity device keeping audience engaged into the story awaiting the revelation of the real reason behind Yi-An´s harmless yet disturbing behaviour. A Fish Out of Water alternates between realism of a struggle of autistic boy and supernatural of a possessed child. Occasionaly, the unknown diagnosis appears to be a red herring, a formal purpose employed as a dramaturgic instrument.

Nurished by the ambivalance, the writer-director cements the overal style of the film in the vein of civil strain of magic/poetic realism. The son acts as an attention rod and it certainly lubes the tackling of social issues sandwiched between young and elderly generations.

Lai Kuo-An sidesteps the usual tropes and clichés of family drama and approaches the conflict from the brighter side of a poverty porn composition. The child´s perspective softens the abrasiveness usually associated with the topic and its formalism. Despite Lai Kuo-An´s empathic approach, the film avoids sentimental pitfalls and as such remains targeted primarily at adult audience.

A Fish Out of Water is indeed a refreshing spin on dysfunctional family storied framed by social realism and Lai-Kuo An demonstrates how an overwrought topic can be refurbished by wielding a different style with which it is not usually coupled. In Lai Kuo-An´s case, the form keeps the substance engaging.

Yi-An´s storyline could be regarded as a minor one and complementary to the development of the character of the mother however Lai Kuo-An´s scriptwriting engineering designed it as the story´s vertebrae thus creating a space for soft scenes enabling to sustain the rhythm of escalation and de-escalation. Not an emotional rollercoaster nor a tear-jerking theatre of sentimentality and self-pity, the writer-director manages a soft melancholia tone in a variety of shades never exerting the marasmus of desperation.

The pacing and structure lies in a reverse dramaturgic structure making the boy´s illness front and center in faint implication of being the consequence of the parental discord instead of foregrounding the parent´s schism driven by their unfavorable socio-economic situation underwritten under their deteriorating relationship.

Lai Kuo-An revamps dysfunctional family story and rehashes social realism drama by renewing the usual stylistic and formal inventory. A Fish Out of Water injects dreaminess and melancholia counterbalancing the civil and bleak set-up. The debuting Taiwanese filmmaker proves that re-imagining a story through child´s eyes raises the audience engagement levels along empathy without undermining the importance of the message nor the targeted audience demography.

A Fish Out of Water

Director(s)
  • Kuo-An Lai
Cast
  • Jen-Shuo Cheng
  • Peggy Tseng
  • Run-yin Bai
  • Han-Yi Yao
Sign-In to Vote
Screen Anarchy logo
Do you feel this content is inappropriate or infringes upon your rights? Click here to report it, or see our DMCA policy.
Pingyao 2017Pingyao Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon International Film FestivalKuo-An LaiJen-Shuo ChengPeggy TsengRun-yin BaiHan-Yi YaoDrama