Contributing Writer; Toronto, Canada (@triflic)
to Vote
Review:  TRUE GRIT
With their love of American film genres, and a penchant for turning them inside out whilst still offering solid examples of whatever they do, be it the gangster picture (Miller's Crossing), the noir (Blood Simple, The Man Who Wasn't There), the 'based-on-a-true-story' (Fargo, even if it sort of wasn't), and screw-ball comedy (Intolerable Cruelty, Raising Arizona), it was only a matter of time that they got to The Western, the most iconic of them all.  Now they sort of went there with No Country For Old Men, a revisionist western set in the 1980s, complete with all the violence and nihilism fixins, but True Grit feels a lot more like a classic western, a good heaping dose of American myth-making where the brothers are more interested in classic entertainment, and leave the snark and the irony to only small scribbles in the margins (an Indian is hung before he can get his final statement to the crowd for instance, or Indian children are casually kicked around like stray dogs for another).  Oddly enough, this is probably the closest the film the Coens have made in their career to what one might call a 'family film.'  Certainly in the fine tradition of the American family film, that has been all but morphed into puerile Adam Sandler comedies or Pixar animated kids films.  

Here you have Mattie Ross (Hailee Steinfeld), a 14 year old girl, with the gift of language and precociousness that serves her well on her quest to bring her father's killer, no-account low-life Tom Chaney to justice (or retribution.) It is telling that she goes after hiring trigger-happy Marshall, Rooster Cogburn (Jeff Bridges at his most grizzled) over the advice of a local on a more by-the-book bounty hunter (having met neither these men at this point, never meeting the latter at all.)  She wants someone that can get things done, and if a few people get shot along the way, so be it, that's life on the frontier.  Things get complicated when another competing bounty hunter, a Texas Ranger (Matt Damon), is also looking for Chaney, to bring him back to Texas.  Mattie insists on accompanying these two men to see that her interests are maintained in the matter, even if they are at odds with the Rangers.  Being the feisty and a very much hands on type, who can sell horses to a veteran horse-trader and then buy them back in the next sentence at a fraction of the price (a nice Coen commentary on the nature of our American Capitalism and self-interested rationalization), she ends up joining them despite their trying to brush her off.  

Thus three completely different people, who despite all speaking English, more or less speak three different languages, set out into Indian country to make the no-account accountable and learn a few things about themselves along the way.   The films most amusing scene (for me anyway) is set in a cabin in the middle of nowhere and finds the trio debating the finer points of Latin as a come-down after some up-close and personal violence.  Using dialogue lifted directly from Charles Portis novel (also used in the previous John Wayne starring adaptation from 1969), one can see the attraction of the material to these particular directors.  They craft the film with impeccable cinematography from Roger Deakins, and layer in a winning, quite traditional piano score.  There is a smidgen of their deadpan sense of humour (evidence being the lengthy and hilarious court-room cross-examination of Cogburn in which his casual violence and justification for it is played for dry laughs.)  Much like their previous film with Jeff Bridges, The Big Lebowski, there is the idea of turning a goof and layabout into a 'Man' that gets things done, without dropping his essential goofiness or layaboutness (witness Cogburn and Ranger LaBeouf shooting their foodstuffs in a contest while they are trekking about in the wilderness in winter with not a lot of food around.)  Not to mention the villains in the piece are either brutally clueless (Josh Brolin essays the wounded, menacing brute to a tee) or in the case of Lucky Ned, not really having a beef other than that they have came into unforeseen proximity of the trio while employing Tom.  Barry Pepper's full on transformation into Harry Dean Stanton is certainly a sight to be seen.  But when there is a race-with-the-devil ride for medical attention, it is played like a straight-up act of heroism, and it plays very, very well.   Funny that the Coens then undercut that 'moment of triumph' with another trope of the Western, the decline of the frontier, which is shown here as an epilogue that feels more like the traditional Coen tone than the rest of the film.  I guess they just could not resist mythologizing American and then taking a little bit of the piss out of the place too.  That is what they do best.

to Vote
Screen Anarchy logo
Do you feel this content is inappropriate or infringes upon your rights? Click here to report it, or see our DMCA policy.

More about True Grit

Thomas MadsenDecember 25, 2010 5:22 PM

RCW.......Really Cannot Wait for this flick to come to town. I expect a lot from the Coen Bros. and I hope i wont be dissapointed. Happy X-mas.

sasaucedo20June 10, 2011 3:59 PM

I haven't read or seen any of the movies or book of "True Grit". I heard they where all great from a co-worker at DISH, he really enjoyed the plot as well as the characters. I just bought the book and plan on reading it and then renting the original movie. Every review that I have read has been good but compared all three of these things. So I'm hoping when I see the new movie on PPV in HD that I like it and it's not a disappointment.